Просмотр отдельного сообщения
Старый 09.06.2014, 13:40   #1997
Entwife
мне это не нужно, да...
 
Аватар для Entwife
 
Регистрация: 22.09.2012
Сообщений: 16,248
Лайки: 1,525
Даг Адамс в Твиттере просто и популярно разъяснил, что написанный Говардом Шором мордорский аккомпанемент Descending Third, который звучит в саундтреке ВК, не имеет ничего общего с Dies Irae.

Oh dear, I guess I hadn't realized that the #LOTR / #DiesIrae thing was still the subject of ongoing debates. Here it is in a nutshell:
Here's the #DiesIrae (pitch names added for non-readers):


And here's #HowardShore's Descending Third motif from #LOTR:

I've centered both on a D-minor tonality to give them a fighting chance, but as you can see, pitch and rhythmic content are different.
A musical *quote* is a definitive thing. It's (essentially) exact and it's purposeful. A musical *reference* is more objective, of course.
In this case, #HowardShore has said that the Descending Third motif is *not* a quote of the #DiesIrae, which pretty much puts it to bed.
However, if people want to call it "#DiesIrae-flavored," that's more a matter of subjective interpretation.
Personally, I think even the case for an accidental *reference* is stretching things.
After all, Sousa's "Stars and Stripes" has more in common with the #DiesIrae than #LOTR does!
__________________
...А что ещё нам остаётся? Творить! Смеяться! Побеждать! (с)
Even little Niggle in his old home could glimpse the Mountains far away, and they got into the borders of his picture; but what they are really like, and what lies beyond them, only those can say who have climbed them.

ОГЛАВЛЕНИЕ ТРЕДА Р. АРМИТИДЖА и ТОРИНА
Entwife вне форума   Ответить с цитированием