Цитата:
Первоначальное сообщение от Tivien
Я, конечно, извиняюсь, но может, не будем паниковать раньше времени? НИКТО из нас еще не видел, как все это выглядит на экране. И вообще, о том, какой же плохой Денетор в фильме, сказано раза два, и то - пуристами.
|
Паниковать и морально готовиться - разные вещи. Простой поиск по всем рецензиям, упомянутым выше в треде, дает следующие неутешительные результаты (не странно ли, что почти все рецензенты испытали приступ порочного пуризма именно на этих сценах):
http://www.theonering.net/perl/newsview/2/1070062286
Same with Denethor - we never really get the sense that he is a good and noble man who has fallen low. He seems spiteful, rather than tragic. His sons are so noble, I found that incongruous.
http://www.exisle.net/mb/index.php?act=ST&f=12&t=10099&
Sure, there were a lot of freaky looking orcs and Uruks. And there were a bunch of nasty cave trolls and the odd giant spider. But the ugliest creature by far had to be Denethor, marvelously portrayed in his madness and grief by John Noble.
http://www.aintitcool.com/display.cgi?id=16610
Gandalf knocking out Denethor-"RETREEEEEAT!!"-THUNK!.
http://wormtalk.blogspot.com/2003_11...42129478274005
the treatment of Denethor is even worse than that of Faramir and shows that the critique of Tolkien for having 'black and white' characters is incredibly off the mark. Tolkien treats Denethor with great subtlety; Jackson does not -- it's over the top, in fact.
http://outnow.ch/Movies/2003/LordOfTheRings3/
Doch Stadthalter Denethor (John Noble) hat seine Stadt mit dem Tod von Boromir bereits aufgegeben.
http://www.tolkienonline.com/thewhit...threadid=74209
Denethor is played as crazy-disgusting-old-man from the git-go, you never get a sense of the stern and wise Steward from him, he's just portrayed as a loon with bad teeth and a squint. Denethor has no Palantir. The line "Did you think the eyes of the White Tower were blind?" is in, but you wonder exactly what he means by it.
Variety (выше в треде)
There, they find a kingdom in decline under a steward, Denethor (John Noble), so distraught over the death of his elder son that his rash decisions are not to be trusted.
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr...ent_id=2047029
a fight which faithless Denethor turns away from when he gives into fear and fatherly pride by sending Faramir to certain death. It's the leadership-tested Gandalf (Ian McKellen) who commands the defense of the city. Although Denethor comes off too as enigmatic compared to the original material, he sure has a spectacular final scene.
http://www.theonering.net/perl/newsview/8/1070761888
I have serious reservations about the characterization of Denethor
http://www.theonering.net/staticnews/1070733320.html
Denethor and the pyre - greeeaat scene (his actual demise has been dramatized, but its really cool).