Толкин смотрел на Добро и Зло иначе. Письмо 183, один из основных наших источников, в котором отражется взгляд Толкина на Добро и зло:
"Still there are clear cases: e.g. acts of sheer cruel aggression, in which therefore right is from the beginning wholly on one side, whatever evil the resentful suffering of evil may eventually generate in members of the right side. There are also conflicts about important things or ideas. In such cases I am more impressed by the extreme importance of being on the right side, than I am disturbed by the revelation of the jungle of confused motives, private purposes, and individual actions (noble or base) in which the right and the wrong in actual human conflicts are commonly involved. If the conflict really is about things properly called right and wrong, or good and evil, then the rightness or goodness of one side is not proved or established by the claims of either side; it must depend on values and beliefs above and independent of the particular conflict."
А подобные логические ошибки:
- возникают как следствие представлений о том, что Добро и Зло - две разные и равные по силе метафизические силы (прошу прощения за тавтологию). Мировоззрению Толкина же, как известно, дуализм был чужд.